Divine works


eng deu рус


USSR without KGB:

§ On the scientific nature of alternative history:

Thesis "History has no subjunctive mood" - has a propaganda role and reason. -
The underdevelopment of the science of the laws of history contributes to its falsification.

Yes, on the first hand, historical reasons determine historical consequences.
History is stable in the sense of the minor role of the individual in history, etc. - "Butterfly Effect" does not work in history - in a statistically overwhelming majority of cases. -
Those who speculate about alternatives simply do not know or do not consider all the factors.

But, on the other hand, the history itself on Earth is accidental, it could be completely different.
Modeling different conditions is an acceptable and fruitful method for studying the laws of history, since the necessary scientific experiment in history is possible only - with the help of modeling. -
Purely observational science is incomplete. Even astronomers develop astronomy primarily through computer simulations.

§ USSR without KGB:

The Cheka (terrorist state organization) was born in the Russian Civil War in 1918-20.
Moreover, it was not so much the commissars who fought for personal power as the victorious communist ideology prompted the soldiers to massively kill the peasants protesting against the `` surplus appropriation ''; - state robbery.
If we remove this factor, then, perhaps, a repressive institution would not have developed in Russia:
- after the end of World War I, there was almost no external threat for a large united country,
- and the peasants themselves did not want the return of the landlords and the monarchy.
Without the Cheka, not a dictatorship would have been established, but a completely democratic republic.
Discontent would not be suppressed, but served the development, including of communism itself.
The communist ideology would not fight by repressing the carriers of other ideologies, but in a civilized manner. -
Repression was not a central or necessary part of it.
On the contrary, the founders of communism wrote about the liberation of man and about democracy.

§ The paradox of popular unanimity:

Yes, & quot; white & quot; terror was not inferior to red - during the Civil War, but:
1. Tsarist repressions were ten times lower than repressions on behalf of the people.
2. Even if the white dictator won, he would have to seek support among the workers, different Social Revolutionaries would survive, there would be fewer victims and long-term negative consequences.

§ The main enemies of communism were the main communists. -

The use of repressive practices by communism did not help him, but, on the contrary, was the main reason for his death. -
The attitude towards communism at the beginning of the 20th century was quite favorable - both in Russia and in the West.
It was the overwhelming nature of communism that pushed people away from it, first in the West, and then in the USSR itself.
In fact, the extremist CPSU (Communist Party of the Soviet Union) has become the main pest and enemy not only for communism, but for the entire left movement on Earth.

The suppression was not directed at the 'exploiters' and not on the `` declassed elements '', but on the people themselves, including the workers.
& quot; Petty bourgeois element & quot; was just a pretext, an excuse. - Power in the bourgeoisie was taken back in 1917.
The purpose of the suppression was to strengthen the power itself.
Under Stalin, the economy grew thanks to the intensification of terror, this, in a vicious circle, intensified terror.

The USSR was buried by the KGB because the USSR was unstable on bayonets, which distorted feedback and created voluntaristic temptations to power.

& quot; Restructuring & quot; in the 1980s, the rulers of the USSR started - because of the decline in the effectiveness of the system, bound on suppression, - because of the cessation of economic growth and because of the growth of opportunism.
The people wanted to get rid of fear, and saw its cause - not in the KGB, but in the CPSU itself.
The rulers of the USSR allowed `` glasnost '', but did not dismantle the suppression organs, so people reacted to the `` lordly '' indulgence with distrust - as to the unreliable company of the temporary eccentric Gorbachev.
& quot; Democratization & quot; an absolute non-democratic System was almost unrealistic. “The upper classes could not rule, the lower classes did not want to.”

The main thing is that terror killed thought, dogmatized and eventually killed Marxism itself.
Gorbachev's personal constructivism was limited to appeals and abstract declarations.
The party apparatus has long been unable not only to develop the calls of the `` leader '', but also to simply implement them. The party apparatus was tuned in only to propaganda.
The various 'Institutes of Marxism' were only part of the party apparatus.

§ It's not about communism:

Communism was rather a rationalization of the absolutist aspirations of the Russian authorities.
There were no greater enemies of communism than the main communists, who cynically used communism as a means of deception.
Communism as an ideology has nothing to do with it. How did Marx concretize the `` dictatorship of the proletariat ''? What would he say if he visited Ukraine in 1932, or Kolyma?
- If Marx had come to life then - in the USSR in the 1930s, he would inevitably have ended up in Kolyma (?)
The Putinist propaganda thesis is that the dissidents were against communism, but when they got rid of communism, now they are demanding something else. - In fact, they just want power.
Anti-communism is not only wrong but ineffective. - The right-wing is playing along with the Putinists in his attempts to split the opposition.

§ Was Rebuilding Possible?

Perhaps Gorbachev (General Secretary of the CPSU) understood this, but it was too late.
A good question for historians - was Perestroika (`` democratization '') possible in the USSR at all, and how?

During Perestroika, I proposed a "Advisory Structure" (3 mailings undertook), but it was a voice in the scorched desert.

§ Deadly Legacy:

The main basis of the USSR was the organs of suppression, this is what turned communism into an artificial ugly utopia, and the USSR into an unstable formation.
Over time, the leading role shifted from violence to propaganda, but this did not change the structure of power. -
When the communist ideology lost its influence in the 1980s, the suppression organs were unable to prevent the collapse of communism and the USSR.
However, they turned out to be strong enough to survive this collapse, and be reborn as the dominant force and terrorist organization (FSB) - already in post-communist Russia, and become the main threat to the existence of mankind.

You can't be forcibly honest.
& quot; Ark of Freedom & quot ;:

Violence caused the moral decay of the Soviet people.
& quot; Morality & quot; Soviet people were reinforced by coercion, so people did not believe in the sincerity of either the bosses or the coerced.
Moreover, they did not believe in the sincerity of their bosses - rightly so:
1. In 1991, the bosses turned from righteous communists into swindlers-anti-communists overnight.
2. Professing righteousness was beneficial. - People have not seen examples of bosses who gave up privileges for the benefit of building communism.

In the end, in the 1990s, the former `` correct '' the Soviet people, which supposedly even `` does not have racism '', turned out to be much more shameless than people living in the `` inhuman jungle '' capitalism.
A positive feedback was formed - the most successful were crooks and raiders.

Now in the West they are surprised at the peculiarities of the national Russian spirituality - indifferent, unprincipled, selfish. Surprised by the thieves' approval in the `` law '' - legal bosses = thieves who steal using the Law. - The Russians believe that the successful is right. The one with the most rights is right.
In the West, they hope for the Law of Transit, that `` contradictions in society become much sharper when one and the same group cannot surrender either power or property, cannot provide the population with either the protection of the law or a normal standard of living. '' (anti-communist Marxist David Sutter)
- They may not wait. - The Russian law of nature is not written. - In the new AI-political-technological reality of moral relativism, different laws will work.

What to do ?:

- Create an alt-Russia with absolute freedom.
`` Russia '', in which moral principles will be exclusively voluntary.

Islamist Satanists:

Yes, sodomy is disgusting. But the `` true believers '' Islamists who rape gays are even more evil. In fact, they are Satanists ..

Democratic mistake:

The main mistake of the Democrats during Perestroika in the USSR, it was that they directed the main blow to the liquidation of the CPSU.
The main blow should have been directed at the elimination of the security forces.

The reason for this error is that ideology, propaganda workers were visible on the surface, while the KGB was hiding.

Nobody believed in the ideology of communism anymore, not even the bosses of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union.
Without reliance on the KGB, the Communist Party of the Soviet Union, unlike in the 1920s, when most of the workers were its volunteers, in the 1990s would have turned into a handful of completely harmless fanatics.

All liberal reforms were carried out already under Gorbachev, Yeltsin only liquidated parliamentarism and handed over power to the KGB.

& quot; Anarchy & quot; - the raider-division of factories took place even with the preservation of strong power structures, moreover, he was headed by them.
Without the former KGB and the Ministry of Internal Affairs, it would not have been worse - it would have appeared instantly:
- Parliamentary law enforcement agencies,
- The militia (not the `` militia '' of the USSR, which was the police) - at the same factories.

Communist theory is right in many ways.
Yes, the causes of Stalinism are already inherent in the theoretical mistakes of Marxism-Leninism, but instead of the revisionism of communism, the democrats primitively simply banned everything leftist, `` threw out the child with water. ''
In addition, in the USSR, Marxism was simply perverted.

Funny stories:

They say that liberals and crap are to blame for everything.
Indeed, a sharp drop in living standards in the former USSR.
However, the 1990s were not a decade of democracy.

In 1991, the people revolted in the USSR.
Fair enough elections to the Soviets were held.
The Soviets began to pursue an independent policy.
& quot; Nomenclature & quot; The Communist Party of the Soviet Union tried to stop the process - organized the Putsch.
The putschists tried to storm the White House in Moscow - the place of the meeting of the Supreme Soviet of the USSR.

However, the people surrounded the White House.
The putschists correctly calculated that the soldiers would go over to the side of the people and would not crush their mothers with tanks if the putschists ordered the storming of the White House.
The rulers acted differently - they proclaimed the process, - they nominated the `` Leader of Russian Democracy '' `` revolutionary '' Yeltsin.
Yeltsin's brigade managed to:
1. Destroy an independent democracy - she shot from tanks at the White House and killed his defenders.
2. To compromise democracy in such a way that the people decided that:
a. Democracy really was in Russia, and that
b. Dictatorship is better than democracy.
But, since together with the led `` democracy '' her leader also compromised himself, then he had to be replaced by a `` patriot '' Putin.

During the assault on the White House there were cool overlays.
For safety reasons, the authorities gave the order to storm - various KGB departments.
Naturally, there were no horizontal ties between the departments, and the supreme command issued an order - informally, so that he would not be executed in case of failure, and no longer participated in the assault.
The platoon leader of the KGB attack aircraft meets other attack aircraft, they say that they are also storming the White House. The commander asks the authorities - is it true - the mind is answered - no - kill them. The commander performs.
20 years later, the killed stormtroopers were awarded the `` Heroes of Russia '', posthumously